CFE-Fraud-Prevention-and-Deterrence Certified Fraud Examiner - Fraud Prevention and Deterrence Exam Questions and Answers

Understanding Behaviorism and Punishment:

Behaviorists like B. F. Skinner argue that punishment temporarily suppresses undesired behaviors rather than eliminating them.

Once the punitive stimulus is removed, the behavior is likely to reappear unless it is replaced with a more desirable behavior through reinforcement.

Analysis of Options:

B. Permanently suppressed: This contradicts the principles of behaviorism, as punishment alone does not permanently modify behavior.

C. Occur more frequently: Punishment typically decreases behavior temporarily.

D. Not affected by punishment: Punishment impacts behavior, but the effect is often temporary.

Conclusion:The most likely outcome is that the behavior will return once the punishment ceases.

References:ACFE resources on behavioral psychology and fraud prevention strategies​​.

 Criminogenic Nature of Organizations:

Research suggests that organizational culture and pressures can override an individual's personal values, especially when authority figures issue direct orders to engage in unethical behavior.

 Why B is Correct:

Strong personal values do not guarantee resistance to unethical orders, as obedience to authority is a powerful psychological force, as seen in studies like the Milgram experiment​​.

 Implication for Fraud Prevention:

Organizations must establish strong ethical environments to reduce the influence of authority pressure on employees

The G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance emphasize the importance of promoting transparent and fair markets and ensuring the efficient allocation of resources. These principles provide a framework applicable across various jurisdictions, aiming to enhance the integrity and functioning of financial markets globally.

=================

General Approaches to Control Corporate Crime:

Common approaches include government intervention, consumer action, and voluntary corporate changes.

Financial institution funding is not typically listed as a direct control mechanism for corporate crime.

Analysis of Options:

B. Government intervention: Effective through regulation and enforcement.

C. Consumer action: Encourages ethical practices through market pressures.

D. Voluntary corporate changes: Demonstrates internal commitment to compliance.

Conclusion:Withdrawal of financial institution funding is not one of the recognized general approaches.

References:ACFE and corporate governance literature on controlling corporate crime​​.

Findings from the 2020 Report to the Nations:

Tips are the most common method of detecting fraud, accounting for over 40% of detected cases.

Whistleblower hotlines and other reporting mechanisms are vital for obtaining tips.

Analysis of Other Options:

A. Internal audit: While effective, it is less common than tips.

B. Confession: Rarely the initial method of detection.

D. External audit: Detects fraud in a smaller percentage of cases.

Conclusion:Tips are the most common method of fraud detection according to the 2020 Report to the Nations.

References:2020 ACFE Report to the Nations on Occupational Fraud and Abuse​​.

 Responsibilities of the Board of Directors:

The board is primarily responsible for oversight, governance, and ensuring the organization operates in the best interest of stakeholders. Key responsibilities include:

Acting as intermediaries between shareholders and management.

Safeguarding resources and assets.

Assessing management’s strategies and decisions.

 Why C is Correct:

Directing employees is a management responsibility, not a board function. The board focuses on oversight rather than operational execution.

 References:

ACFE governance principles emphasize the separation of oversight and operational roles​​.

Purpose of Anti-Fraud Education:

Education is most effective when employees understand the real consequences of fraud. Providing examples of prior incidents reinforces the importance of compliance.

Analysis of Other Options:

A. Include detection procedures: While this can increase awareness, it risks exposing sensitive controls.

C. Restricting to formal mechanisms: Education should be flexible and incorporate informal, ongoing messaging.

D. Executives and professionals only: While they play an essential role, education should engage employees at all levels.

Conclusion:Including examples of prior misconduct effectively conveys the seriousness of fraud prevention.

References:ACFE best practices for fraud education programs​​.

Proactive Fraud Auditing Procedures:

Analytical reviews are effective for identifying large or unusual trends and anomalies, not necessarily small frauds.

Other tools, such as detailed transaction testing, are better suited for uncovering small frauds.

Analysis of Other Options:

A. Element of surprise: A key feature of fraud audits.

C. Fraud assessment questioning: Valid as part of the audit process.

D. Management’s intentions: Proactive procedures signal a strong stance against fraud.

Conclusion:Option B is false because analytical reviews are better at detecting significant anomalies rather than small frauds.

References:ACFE materials on fraud auditing techniques​​.

Step by Step Comprehensive Detailed Explanation with All References:

Proactive Fraud Auditing:

Proactive fraud audit procedures aim to prevent and detect fraud before it escalates. Implementing these procedures signals to employees and stakeholders that fraud will not be tolerated.

Such actions align with creating a strong anti-fraud culture within the organization.

Examples of Proactive Fraud Audits:

Surprise audits, continuous monitoring, and analytical procedures identify discrepancies and potential fraud risks.

Fraud prevention and deterrence are enhanced through consistent implementation.

Effectiveness and Prevention:

Unlike reactive measures, proactive approaches demonstrate an organization’s commitment to maintaining integrity and ethical standards​​.

Rational Choice Theory Overview:

This theory posits that individuals consciously weigh the benefits and risks of committing a crime and make calculated decisions to engage in criminal behavior if the perceived benefits outweigh the risks.

Deterrence Mechanism:

Crime can be deterred by reducing opportunities (e.g., strong internal controls) and increasing the likelihood of detection and punishment (e.g., effective monitoring systems).

Why Other Options are Incorrect:

A. Routine activities theory: Focuses on the convergence of motivated offenders, suitable targets, and lack of guardianship.

B. Differential association theory: Explains crime as learned behavior through interaction with others.

D. Social conflict theory: Suggests crime results from societal inequalities and power struggles.

Why C is Correct:

Rational choice theory explicitly addresses crime prevention through increased risks and reduced opportunities​​.

References for All Questions:

ACFE Fraud Examination Guide​​.

Criminological theories as applied to fraud prevention and deterrence​​.

Corporate governance frameworks and corruption-related risks​​.

 Fraud Risk Management Program Requirements:

A fraud risk management program includes mechanisms to detect and respond to noncompliance, sanctions for violations, and measures to address control failures.

 Why B is Incorrect:

Responsibility for handling suspected incidents should remain within the organization, typically assigned to compliance officers or internal audit teams. Delegating it to external parties undermines internal governance.

 Why Other Options are Correct:

A, C, and D describe essential elements of a fraud risk management program, including monitoring, sanctions, and corrective measures for anti-fraud controls​​.

Modern Criminological Studies on White-Collar Crime:Studies highlight that white-collar crimes are often influenced by situational factors rather than inherent criminal traits. The availability of organizational opportunities to commit fraud plays a crucial role.

Analysis of Options:

A. Cultural ties: Less significant in white-collar crime.

B. Criminal history: White-collar criminals often have no prior criminal records.

D. Social class: While white-collar crime is associated with higher social classes, the determinant factor is the opportunity presented within an organization.

C. Organizational opportunity: This aligns with the fraud triangle concept, where opportunity is a primary driver.

Conclusion:Organizational opportunity is the determinant aspect of white-collar crime.

References:ACFE study materials and modern criminology texts on white-collar crime​​.

Rational choice theory posits that crime is a deliberate and rational decision made by individuals who weigh the costs and benefits of their actions. Perpetrators commit crimes when they believe the potential benefits outweigh the risks. This theory also supports deterrence measures that increase the perceived risks or reduce the benefits of committing crimes, thereby discouraging rational actors from engaging in fraudulent behavior.

​

=================

 ACFE Code of Professional Ethics:

Fraud examiners must avoid expressing opinions about guilt or innocence. They are tasked with presenting evidence and findings objectively, leaving determinations of guilt to legal or regulatory authorities.

 Why A is Correct:

Maria’s statement that "Rita is guilty" constitutes a violation because it goes beyond the role of a fraud examiner.

 References:

ACFE standards emphasize objectivity and avoidance of subjective judgments in fraud reporting​​.

Fraud Response Responsibilities:

Management is responsible for responding to fraud because they oversee the organization's operations, culture, and compliance frameworks.

Other parties, such as internal auditors and the audit committee, provide oversight and recommendations but do not directly implement responses.

Conclusion:Management has the ultimate responsibility for responding appropriately to fraud.

References:ACFE materials on fraud risk governance and management’s role​​.

Impact of Specialized Departments on Fraud Risk:While specialization improves operational efficiency, it can also create silos, reducing oversight and coordination. This fragmentation may increase the overall fraud risk.

Key Considerations:

Fraud often occurs in areas where controls and communication are weak. Specialized departments may inadvertently facilitate fraud by isolating information.

Cross-departmental collaboration and centralized controls are essential to mitigate these risks.

Conclusion:The existence of many specialized departments increases the risk of fraud if not properly managed.

References:ACFE recommendations on risk management and departmental coordination​​.

Differential Reinforcement Theory:

This theory suggests behavior is strengthened when positive rewards are gained or punishment is avoided, not weakened.

The premise is the opposite of what the statement claims.

Conclusion:The statement is incorrect because differential reinforcement strengthens, not weakens, behavior.

References:ACFE discussions on behavioral theories and fraud prevention​​.

 Key Elements of Routine Activities Theory:

This criminological theory asserts that crime is likely when three conditions converge:

Availability of suitable targets.

Absence of capable guardians (e.g., security or oversight).

Presence of motivated offenders.

 Why C is Correct:

Routine activities theory focuses on the environmental and situational factors that facilitate crime, making it distinct from other criminological theories.

 Why Other Options are Incorrect:

A (Rational choice theory): Focuses on individual decision-making.

B (Differential association theory): Emphasizes learning criminal behavior through interaction.

D (Social control theory): Focuses on societal bonds preventing crime​​.

Ethical Responsibilities of a CFE:

Under the ACFE Code of Professional Ethics, a Certified Fraud Examiner has the responsibility to report all relevant findings honestly and comprehensively, even if no fraud is identified.

Rule 2 states that CFEs must "perform all professional engagements with due diligence" and report any material findings.

Expressing Opinions on Deficient Controls:

CFEs are expected to provide constructive recommendations, including noting control deficiencies that could lead to fraud or operational risks.

Failing to express an opinion on deficiencies would not align with professional standards of diligence and full disclosure.

Conclusion:Black is permitted, and indeed encouraged, to express his professional opinion on the deficient controls as part of his ethical obligations.

References:ACFE Code of Professional Ethics, specifically rules related to diligence and full disclosure​​.

Principles in the Fraud Risk Management Guide (COSO and ACFE):

Communicating expectations regarding fraud risk management.

Conducting comprehensive fraud risk assessments.

Implementing preventive and detective controls.

Monitoring and reporting the program’s effectiveness.

Analysis of Option D:

Fraud risk management requires ongoing evaluations, not one-time assessments, to adapt to evolving risks.

Conclusion:Option D is not included in the principles described in the Fraud Risk Management Guide.

References:COSO-ACFE Fraud Risk Management Guide​​.

The Treadway Commission emphasizes improving internal controls, which include strengthening the internal audit function. Providing adequate resources and authority to the internal audit function ensures that it operates independently and effectively, which is critical for preventing and detecting fraud. The internal audit function can evaluate financial reporting systems, detect irregularities, and provide valuable recommendations for improvement. This recommendation aligns with the goal of reducing fraud and ensuring reliable financial reporting.

​

=================

 Responsibility of Auditors:

Under International Standards on Auditing (ISA) 240, auditors are required to investigate any indications of fraud, regardless of the materiality of the misstatement.

Evidence of intentional misstatements indicates the potential for broader fraudulent activity, necessitating a reassessment of audit procedures.

 Importance of Fraud Indicators:

Even if the misstatement does not exceed the materiality threshold, it represents a significant risk factor that could compromise the reliability of the financial statements.

 Why B is Correct:

Adjusting audit procedures ensures that the audit team addresses the broader implications of the fraud risk while maintaining professional skepticism and compliance with auditing standards​​.

Social Control Theory Overview:

This theory posits that individuals consider social and personal relationships when deciding whether to commit a crime. They reflect on the potential consequences of their actions on their relationships and social standing.

Application to the Scenario:

The question of "What will my spouse think?" aligns directly with social control theory, as it involves weighing personal consequences within a social context.

Analysis of Other Options:

B. Operant theory: Focuses on behavior modification through rewards and punishments.

C. Cognitive theory: Centers on thought processes and decision-making patterns.

D. Behavioral theory: Examines the external influences on behavior, not personal social relationships.

Conclusion:Social control theory best explains the scenario.

References:Criminological theories referenced in ACFE study materials​​.

Fraud Risk Management Program Requirements:

Effective fraud risk management programs ensure transparency, consistency, and fairness.

Sanctions for noncompliance should be transparent and communicated to demonstrate a commitment to accountability.

Analysis of Options:

A. Mechanisms for breaches: Necessary to address compliance issues.

B. Consistent and firm punishment: Ensures a deterrent effect.

D. Designated compliance monitors: Vital for program enforcement.

C. Enacted privately: This is false because transparency is essential to maintain trust and deter similar actions.

Conclusion:Option C is false as formal sanctions should be communicated appropriately to promote deterrence and accountability.

References:ACFE materials on fraud risk management and enforcement practices​​.

Findings from the 2020 Report to the Nations:

A. Complaints about management: Not the most common red flag; lifestyle changes, such as living beyond means, are more common.

B. Gender of fraudsters: The report consistently shows that men commit more occupational frauds than women.

C. Median losses by executives vs. staff: Losses caused by executives are significantly higher.

D. Past offenses: Most fraudsters do not have a prior fraud-related disciplinary history.

Conclusion:Option B aligns with the findings of the 2020 Report to the Nations.

References:2020 ACFE Report to the Nations​​.

International Standards on Auditing (ISAs) Requirements:

ISAs require auditors to communicate suspected or confirmed fraud to "those charged with governance" of the organization, as they have the responsibility for oversight.

ISA 240, “The Auditor's Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements,” mandates that findings be reported to appropriate governance bodies before considering further actions.

Confidentiality and Legal Obligations:

Auditors must maintain confidentiality unless legal or regulatory frameworks require disclosure to authorities. Immediate reporting to law enforcement (option B) may breach confidentiality without proper internal escalation.

Why Option D is Correct:

Reporting to governance ensures proper internal actions are taken and protects the integrity of the audit process. It allows the organization to address the issue before external involvement if required.

References:

ISA 240 and the ACFE guidelines on professional auditor conduct​​.

Understanding Behavioral Responses:

Positive reinforcement: Increases desired behavior by providing rewards.

Negative reinforcement: Increases desired behavior by removing an unfavorable condition.

Punishment: Reduces undesired behavior by introducing a negative consequence or removing a positive condition.

Application to the Scenario:

Demotion is a punitive action designed to discourage the employee’s poor performance, making it an example of punishment.

Conclusion:The manager’s action aligns with the concept of punishment.

References:ACFE guidance on behavioral theory and management practices​​.

 CFE Ethical Responsibilities:

As per the ACFE Code of Professional Ethics, fraud examiners must ensure transparency in their professional conduct. They cannot promise confidentiality if the information must be disclosed to management or other authorities as part of the investigation.

 Why D is Correct:

Agreeing to confidentiality in this situation would breach ethical and legal obligations, especially if the information pertains to fraud or misconduct that the organization needs to address.

 Why Other Options are Incorrect:

A and B: Attempting to maintain confidentiality is misleading and unprofessional.

C: Taking the request directly to management without clarification could breach trust prematurely​​.

 ACFE Code of Professional Ethics:

The ACFE Code of Ethics prohibits fraud examiners from making absolute statements about the absence of fraud. Fraud cannot be definitively ruled out based on an examination's findings.

 Why B is Correct:

Stevens cannot state that the organization is "free of fraud," as fraud detection is inherently limited by the scope and methods of the examination. Such a statement could mislead stakeholders and compromise ethical standards​​.

Fraud Risk Assessment Objectivity:

The assessment must remain unbiased, but any prior disagreements or conflicts may highlight areas where policies or procedures are unclear, increasing fraud risks.

Why C is Correct:

Incorporating disagreements provides context to evaluate risks objectively, ensuring that all relevant factors are considered without bias.

Why Other Options are Incorrect:

A: Confronting Brandon could create further conflict without adding value.

B: Delegating the task unnecessarily avoids responsibility.

D: Automatically designating the area as high-risk lacks justification and could undermine credibility​​.

References for All Questions:

ACFE Code of Professional Ethics and Fraud Examination Guide​​.

ISO 31000:2018 guidelines for risk management​​.

Criminological theories related to crime causation and fraud risk assessments​​.

Best Practices for Vendor Due Diligence:

Including a clause requiring vendors to report misconduct demonstrates a commitment to transparency and ethical standards.

This measure also ensures accountability and provides the organization with critical information about potential issues.

Analysis of Other Options:

A. Internal audits: While valuable, conducting internal audits of vendors before an agreement is impractical and costly.

B. Concealing due diligence efforts: Transparency in due diligence helps build trust with vendors.

C. Post-contract questionnaires: Due diligence must occur before contracts are signed.

Conclusion:Including a contractual clause about misconduct reporting is the most accurate recommendation.

References:ACFE guidelines on vendor due diligence and fraud prevention​​.

Best Practices for Protecting Whistleblowers:

Ensuring a safe environment for whistleblowers is critical to fostering an ethical organizational culture.

Establishing formal consequences for retaliation protects whistleblowers and promotes trust.

Analysis of Options:

A. Rules only for lower-level employees: Whistleblower protections must apply to all employees, regardless of rank.

B. Listing every type of misconduct: Comprehensive policies are good, but they do not need to enumerate all past misconduct.

C. Internal communication only: Communicating whistleblower procedures to external stakeholders (e.g., regulators) can be critical.

D. Formal consequences for retaliation: This is essential to discourage retaliatory actions and ensure fairness.

Conclusion:Establishing formal consequences for retaliation is the most accurate and aligned with best practices.

References:ACFE guidelines on whistleblower protections and ethical policies​​.

Findings from the 2020 Report to the Nations:

Asset misappropriation: Most common form of occupational fraud (e.g., theft of cash or inventory). It is frequent but less costly.

Financial statement fraud: Most costly, involving significant manipulation of financial data.

Analysis of Options:

A. Asset misappropriation; corruption: Corruption is less costly than financial statement fraud.

B. Corruption, asset misappropriation: Incorrect order and does not match the costliest scheme.

C. Financial statement fraud; corruption: Incorrect pairing.

Conclusion:Asset misappropriation is most common, and financial statement fraud is most costly.

References:2020 ACFE Report to the Nations on Occupational Fraud and Abuse​​.

Treadway Commission Recommendations:

Establishing an independent audit committee is essential for oversight and reducing fraud risk in financial reporting.

Audit committees play a critical role in ensuring the integrity of financial statements.

Analysis of Other Options:

A. Shareholder oversight of hotlines: Not a Treadway Commission recommendation.

B. Compensation committee resources: Not directly related to fraud prevention.

C. Management charter: Unrelated to the recommendations.

Conclusion:Mandatory independent audit committees are a key recommendation to reduce fraud risk.

References:Treadway Commission’s Report on Fraudulent Financial Reporting​​.

Responsibility for Anti-Fraud Program Effectiveness:

Management holds ultimate responsibility for designing, implementing, and maintaining an effective anti-fraud program.

Internal and external auditors, as well as compliance functions, provide oversight and recommendations but are not directly responsible for the program's effectiveness.

Conclusion:Management is ultimately accountable for ensuring the success of the anti-fraud program.

References:ACFE guidelines on fraud risk governance and management roles​​.

 Professional Auditing Standards Requirement:

Standards such as the International Standards on Auditing (ISA) and Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS) require auditors to include elements of unpredictability in their audit procedures to reduce the risk of fraud.

 Purpose of Unpredictability:

By varying the scope, timing, and extent of audits, auditors prevent potential fraudsters from anticipating audit procedures and adjusting their behavior.

 Why A is Correct:

This aligns with established auditing principles to enhance fraud detection and maintain audit integrity​​.

Components of COSO’s Enterprise Risk Management Framework:

D. Review and revision: Ensures continuous improvement and adaptation of risk management practices to align with changing circumstances.

A. Event avoidance: Not explicitly listed as a component but is part of broader risk responses.

B. Risk tolerance: An element within risk management but not a separate component.

C. Compliance: A goal of ERM but not a framework component.

Conclusion:Review and revision is a core component of COSO's ERM framework.

References:COSO Enterprise Risk Management Framework—Integrating with Strategy and Performance​​.

 ISSAI Standards:

The International Standards of Supreme Audit Institutions (ISSAI) require government auditors to consider fraud and abuse during financial audits. Abuse includes improper use of authority or resources, which may not always meet the legal threshold of fraud but still warrants attention.

 Expanded Audit Scope:

Unlike private-sector audits, public-sector audits often have broader objectives, requiring vigilance for misuse of public funds and resources.

 Why A is Correct:

Staying alert to abuse ensures comprehensive accountability, aligning with ISSAI's objectives​​.

 Principle Overview:

Responsibility pertains to the duty of an organization to act in the best interest of society, ensuring sustainable and ethical practices that benefit all stakeholders, including employees, customers, and the environment.

 Corporate Governance Definition:

Corporate governance frameworks emphasize corporate responsibility as a key pillar for maintaining societal trust and long-term value creation.

 Why Responsibility is Correct:

While transparency, fairness, and accountability are essential, responsibility uniquely emphasizes societal interests and ethical conduct​​.

 Due Diligence in High-Corruption Risk Transactions:

When operating in high-risk environments, enhanced due diligence is critical. This includes evaluating payment methods, transaction patterns, and the customer's reputation.

 Why A is Correct:

Analyzing purchasing patterns and payment methods helps identify red flags such as unusual payment terms or volumes inconsistent with Green’s business profile.

 Why Other Options are Incorrect:

B: Due diligence is necessary regardless of payment terms.

C: Enhanced due diligence for high-risk countries does not constitute discrimination.

D: Ignoring due diligence poses significant compliance and reputational risks.

 References:

ACFE guidance on due diligence and anti-corruption practices in global commerce​​.

Detective controls are designed to identify fraud or errors that have already occurred. Continuous audit techniques serve as a detective control by automatically monitoring transactions and flagging anomalies or irregularities for further investigation. On the other hand, preventive controls such as separation of duties, background checks, and hiring policies aim to stop fraud before it happens.

=================

Professional Skepticism Defined:

Professional skepticism is an attitude that includes a questioning mind and a critical assessment of evidence. Fraud examiners must remain vigilant to indications of potential fraud throughout an engagement.

Consistent Application:

ACFE standards emphasize that skepticism should be applied consistently, even if initial findings do not indicate fraud, to avoid overlooking potential risks.

Why D is Correct:

Relaxing skepticism can lead to missed evidence or poor judgment, undermining the examination's effectiveness​​.

 Theory of Differential Association:

This theory suggests that criminal behavior is learned through interaction with others, primarily within intimate groups.

Principles of the theory include:

Learning through communication.

Acquiring criminal knowledge similarly to other forms of learning.

 Why A is Incorrect:

General needs and values, such as poverty or desire for wealth, do not directly explain criminal behavior under this theory. Instead, the behavior is attributed to learned influences from others.

 Clarification of Other Options:

B, C, and D accurately reflect the principles of differential association​​.

Hierarchy of Ethical Guidance Sources:

A. Contract law: Provides legal guidance on business agreements.

C. ACFE Code of Professional Ethics: Offers specific ethical standards for fraud examiners.

D. Philosophical principles: Offer foundational guidance on ethics.

B. Family and friends: While valuable for personal advice, they are the lowest reference point in determining professional ethics.

Conclusion:Guidance from family and friends is the lowest level of reference for determining ethical actions.

References:ACFE standards on ethical decision-making​​.

This scenario is an example of punishment. Punishment involves introducing a consequence (in this case, the loss of responsibility for cross-departmental projects) to discourage undesirable behavior. The manager uses this approach to address Devon’s negative attitude and to promote better cooperation with other departments in the future.

=================